Traditional Irish Bread and Butter Pudding Recipe with Cinnamon & Custard (2024)

An Old-Fashioned Dish for Every Age

My traditional Irish bread and butter pudding recipe was a staple in my home (and many Irish homes for donkey’s years) growing up. In fact the exact recipe you’ll see below is the very recipe that my mum would make for us growing up. and has been a staple in many Irish homes for donkey’s years.

Growing up in Ireland, I’m used to eating hearty, comforting desserts like puddings. The UK comes with a lot of cold weather and dark grayish days, so dishes like bread and butter pudding always made for a great way to warm you up and keep you cozy. I might be biased, or perhaps just a wee bit nostalgic, but I personally believe that my mammies’ bread and butter pudding recipe is the best bread pudding recipe I’ve ever had. I just love how the warm cinnamon and egg mixture combines with the buttery bread when it bakes.

History of Bread Pudding

Born from humble beginnings, bread pudding made its first appearance sometime in the 11th century. Originating in the UK, specifically in England, bread pudding became the cure for preventing any wasted food like stale bread. However, instead of milk, homemakers would use water in addition to whatever sweet spices they could afford to get their hands on.

Different Ways to Make Bread Pudding

Like a lot of traditional dishes, this recipe came about as a way to use up leftover, day-old bread, and because there are bread lovers and eaters all over the world, different iterations of bread pudding have appeared in countries like:

• The United States (especially Louisiana) 🇺🇸
• Ireland 🇮🇪
• England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿
• Belgium 🇧🇪
• China 🇨🇳
• Argentina 🇦🇷
• Brazil 🇧🇷
• Malaysia, and more! 🇲🇾

These regional variations lean on different approaches to making the tale-as-old as time dish based on the ingredients sitting around in their pantry or the dishes leftover in their kitchen. See them below:

• Bread pudding using Hawaiian rolls – Portuguese-style sweetened breads and biscuits always make the heart grow fonder.
• Bread pudding using a rice cooker – for an easy, time-saving method to making bread pudding.
• Bread pudding using condensed milk – ideal for using up a long-shelf life ingredient staple.
• Bread pudding using panettone – recycle your classic Italian Christmas dessert with this sweet dough.
• Bread pudding using pillsbury cinnamon rolls – turn an American sweet breakfast staple into a spiced vanilla pull-apart pudding.
• Bread pudding using pound cake – bring new life to a leftover dessert originating from northern Europe.

Scroll to the bottom of the page for an all-around classic bread pudding recipe that’s perfect for virtually any occasion.

Common Bread Types for Bread & Butter Pudding

No matter what type of leftover bread you’ve got in your kitchen, you can find ways to salvage it and turn it into a sweet masterpiece. You can use anything from:

• Plain white bread – breakfast toast bread (sliced or unsliced works wonders), English muffins and naan bread
• Raisin bread – Irish soda bread and cinnamon (raisin) rolls
• Butter heavy breads – sweet brioche buns, braided challah bread, homemade butter rolls, and stale croissants

How to Make Bread & Butter Pudding

Bread pudding is one of the easiest recipes to make to satisfy a sweet tooth on a budget. Read the tips below for ways to make the process go by as smoothly as the butter.

What to Prepare Before Making Bread & Butter Pudding

You can prepare this recipe one day in advance and store it in the fridge until you’re ready to bake it. When you’re ready to start combining the “pudding” mixture with the bread follow these simple steps:

• Step 1: Gather the ingredients and set everything out on your kitchen counter.
• Step 2: Grease whatever cookware you plan to use. Hint: Your taste buds will thank you if you choose to paint melted butter onto the pans.
• Step 3: In order to keep your bread from collapsing, make sure it rises less by whisking, not beating the “pudding” mixture that you’ll end up pouring all over the bread.

Don’t forget to top your Irish Bread & Butter Pudding with freshly whipped cream or even ice cream if you like. I hope you enjoy my Bread & Butter Pudding for St. Patrick’s Day or anytime of year. Hopefully it will warm your heart and home like it did mine.

Kitchen Tools Needed to Make Bread & Butter Pudding

There are a few things you’ll want to have readily available in your kitchen when making this delectable dessert:

• This beautiful Le Creuset Heritage Cover Square Casserole dish is nice and deep to bake your pudding into a softer texture.
• Find a pastry brush that doesn’t shed like my Mason Cash Pastry Brush. You’ll use this to brush your pudding dish generously with butter.
• I served my pudding in a Tag Ivory Sonoma Rimmed Bowl. I’m happy to add these to my collection of treasures because the neutral tone means they fit in anywhere.
• Add this John Boos Chopping Board to your wish list if you haven’t already—it’s life changing. I’m tight on kitchen space, so this board gives me an entirely new (or expanded) surface to work on.

How to Reheat Bread & Butter Pudding

In the microwave

Place a serving size or individual slice portions in a microwave-safe container. Then add a little bit of milk, cream or leftover “pudding” mixture so that it doesn’t dry out upon heating.

In the oven

Preheat the oven to 350(ish) degrees. Then add a little bit of milk, cream or leftover “pudding” mixture, to moisten it up. Then cover up your dish with aluminum foil so that it locks in the heat, add it to the oven, and let it reheat for 10 to 15 minutes. It’s as simple as 1,2,3!

How to Store Bread & Butter Pudding

Store bread pudding in the fridge for no longer than 4 days. After that, feel free to store bread pudding in your freezer for up to three months. For maximum freshness, let your serving size thaw in the fridge overnight before reheating it.

Looking for More Old-World Dinner & Dessert Recipes?

Generational cooking is the best kind of cooking, and the below recipes deserve a comeback. Here are some other traditional treats that have withstood the tests of time and are worth the passing of the baton from one cook to another:

• Try a classic dessert through this Ode to Old-School Birthday Cake recipe
• This Cherry Cobbler Topped with Honey Butter Vanilla Bean Biscuits won’t disappoint anybody
• Get an easy-to-make, retro dinner recipe with Mini Meatloaf 4 Ways
• This No-Sugar Added Apple Tart Will Help You Love Healthier Sweeteners
• Find All the Tips You Need to Make Your First Pie from Scratch
• Get to know Sunday Night Pot Roast 101

Looking for More St. Patrick’s Day Recipes?

Celebrate everything about the Emerald Isle with these Irish-inspired favorites:

• These Festive St. Patrick’s Day Cupcakes will bring the rainbows and lucky pots of gold to any St. Patrick’s Day party
• Throw a festive St. Pat’s Day get-together with these Easy Guinness Ice Cream Floats
• Celebrate St. Paddy’s with these classic Homemade Shamrock Shakes
• Try this Reuben-Style Corned Beef Hash Recipe
• Learn How to Make Gluten-Free Shepherd’s Pie